Wikipedia:Peer review/Rihanna: Live in Concert Tour/archive1
| Toolbox |
|---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I'm not sure if it is capable of achieving GA status, so any comments on how to best improve would be appreciated. I know it's quite short and there is a lack of prose.
Thanks, Aaron • You Da One 11:52, 11 August 2012 (UTC)
- Comments by Gongshow
Looking at several concert tour GAs - including ones for Madonna (Drowned World Tour, Re-Invention World Tour, Confessions Tour), Mariah Carey (Butterfly World Tour), Britney Spears (The M+M's Tour), Lady Gaga (The Fame Ball Tour, The Monster Ball Tour), Gwen Stefani (Harajuku Lovers Tour), and Miley Cyrus (Wonder World Tour) - there appear to be some common characteristics:
- "Background" - interviews/articles discussing plans to tour, announcements of tour dates, reports of ticket sales/venue sellouts.
- "Synopsis" - what the shows typically consisted of, including themes, costumes, choreography, setlists and encores, etc.
- "Reception" - reviews from journalists/critics, and commercial reception is useful as well (how much the tour grossed).
- "Broadcasts and recordings" (optional) - Some of the GAs have this section, which includes related DVD releases and/or TV broadcasts.
- "Personnel" (optional) - Some of the GAs have this section, which includes a listing of the band, production team, etc.
Now looking at the Rihanna: Live in Concert Tour article, I think the "Opening Act", "Setlist", and "Tour Dates" sections look good (assuming the "citation needed"s are cleaned up). As for the next step, I suggest adding sections of prose ("Background", "Synopsis", "Reception") and expanding the lead so that the article is comparable to Britney's The M+M's Tour article. I hope this helps. Gongshow Talk 18:28, 20 August 2012 (UTC)