User talk:John Yunshire/Archives/2023/April

Edit warring

Hi, I see that you are in a content dispute with IP user 124.197.207.130 among other IPs on Durumagi, Geomungo and other various articles. I suggest that you follow the Wikipedia:Dispute resolution protocol when you get into a disagreement with other editors, as constantly reverting their content back is considered edit warring, which is prohibited and can lead to being blocked from editing. Try and communicate with the other user(s) on their talk page or on the article talk page first, and if that does not work out then you can proceed to the next step in the dispute resolution page. If they refuse to communicate at all then you can report the user(s) at WP:AN/I or WP:ANEW. Hope this helps a lot. AP 499D25 (talk) 13:41, 2 April 2023 (UTC)

Notice of Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents discussion

There is currently a discussion at Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents regarding an issue with which you may have been involved. The thread is Disruptive editing / edit warring on Korea articles, possible block evasion. Thank you. AP 499D25 (talk) 05:51, 4 April 2023 (UTC)

Hi, could you read through and maybe respond to the latest comment in the ANI thread linked above? AP 499D25 (talk) 11:04, 5 April 2023 (UTC)

About Korean Cultures

I want to talk about edit war you are involved in. These articles are about Korean cultures, but I think the contents of articles are too biased towards perspective of China. About Durumagi, No other documents can be found that explain that Durumagi originated from clothes of Han Chinese clothing except Samuel Lee's brochure. And About Geomungo, although there may be records that geomungo and Wo Konghou are similar, there's no certain documents that Geomungo is derived from Wo Konghou. Rather, Korean history book says that Geomungo is modeled after Guqin. As an aside, National Gugak Center of Korea raises a hypothesis that origin of Geomungo is Traditional Korean Instrument before Guqin was introduced.

If the articles are left unattended, the people searching about Korean culture would receive wrong information or misunderstand about Korean culture.

It is true Korean cultures have been heavily influenced by Chinese culture, but it has been localized into their own style for a long time and their local style that can't be found in Chinese culture appear in their culture. Japanese Culture and Vietnamese Culture are too. Currently English Wikipedia is focused on Chinese Perspective in the articles of East Asian cultures than Chinese Wikipedia.

At least Chinese Wikipedia admits that East Asian Common culture that appears in China as well is Culture of China but also Culture of Various Asian Countries. Especially, This point stands out in the articles about garments of East Asia.

I hope you not to spark edit war anymore and make the articles into neutral contents referring wikipedia of several languages. Kenneth Goh (talk) 15:33, 10 April 2023 (UTC)

About Korean Cultures

※I post it again since the previous one is removed and you didn't respond to it.

I want to talk about edit war you are involved in. These articles are about Korean cultures, but I think the contents of articles are too biased towards perspective of China. About Durumagi, No other documents can be found that explain that Durumagi originated from clothes of Han Chinese clothing except Samuel Lee's brochure. And About Geomungo, although there may be records that geomungo and Wo Konghou are similar, there's no certain documents that Geomungo is derived from Wo Konghou. Rather, Korean history book says that Geomungo is modeled after Guqin. As an aside, National Gugak Center of Korea raises a hypothesis that origin of Geomungo is Traditional Korean Instrument before Guqin was introduced.

If the articles are left unattended, the people searching about Korean culture would receive wrong information or misunderstand about Korean culture.

It is true Korean cultures have been heavily influenced by Chinese culture, but it has been localized into their own style for a long time and their local style that can't be found in Chinese culture appear in their culture. Japanese Culture and Vietnamese Culture are too.

Currently English Wikipedia is focused on Chinese Perspective in the articles of East Asian cultures than Chinese Wikipedia.

At least Chinese Wikipedia admits that East Asian Common culture that appears in China as well is Culture of China but also Culture of Various Asian Countries. Especially, This point stands out in the articles about garments of East Asia.

I hope you not to spark edit war anymore and make the articles into neutral contents referring wikipedia of several languages. Kenneth Goh (talk) 05:56, 17 April 2023 (UTC)