Talk:Hobitit/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: AryKun (talk · contribs) 03:47, 20 January 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Link television miniseries.
- Surely not worth linking such a common and self-explanatory term.
The lead's quite short, could be expanded with reception, production, etc.
- Extended
"adapts quite faithfully the events until" → "adapts the events in the book faithfully until"
- Fixed.
Hobbits should be capitalized, this needs to be done throughout the article.
- Fixed.
Add Frodo and Sam's last names
- Done.
"The series is divided into nine episodes" → Maybe move this later into the paragraph, after mentioning what the series is based on.
- Done.
Link War of the Ring.
- Done.
Add Merry and Pippin's last names, and maybe specify that these are their nicknames.
- Added; not sure this article is that place for talking about nicknames.
"the Barrow-wight" → "a Barrow-wight"?
- All right; only one is ever encountered but there must once have been many.
Link Fellowship of the Ring at first mention instead of second.
- Done.
Link Orc.
- Done.
"Gandalf apparently dies." → " Gandalf apparently dies in a fight with a Balrog." Since you mention the Balrog later.
- Done.
It isn't mentioned that Strider is actually Aragorn.
- Added.
"new family-produced" → Is this necessary? Also, what does family-produced mean?
- Yes, it's a distinctive feature. It just means "produced by members of a family", as it sounds.
"such as" → "including"
- OK for variety, it's not exactly better.