Talk:Galushka

Don't remove revert official census statistic for this name

https://ridni.org/?lang=english It is official census stat represented by Genealogy group of Ukraine. If you have something personal against it please explain it here Yuriykuzin (talk) 08:57, 26 December 2024 (UTC)

Problems with your edits:

• this website is of unknown expertise and credibility.
• It is a commercvial website and Wikipedia is no a vehicle for its promotion
• Its statistics if for an unknown date hence the information is not reliable for an encyclopedia
• Finally, you are reverting to wrong etymology. Galushka is derived from word "halushka" not from "halushky"

Therefore your edit is reverted. Please do not restore your edit befor resolving the disagreements. --Altenmann >talk 20:55, 3 January 2025 (UTC)

• Unknown for you, you can go to ukrainian wiki and remove it there. As I said and it is official census data. It is exists in Ukr wiki.
• Sorry it's not commercial, read domain names right, ".org" non profitable organization and that is a case. so no any ad here.
• date known.
• it is the only one that I can barely agree because to say singular galushka possible but actually nobody using it but surnames.

Yuriykuzin (talk) 22:00, 3 January 2025 (UTC)

• ukrainian wiki has no say in English wiki

  Yes it is commercial because it sells genealogy and DNA tests, but I can let it fly, because the (useful) work of the society must be paid somehow.

  No the date is not known. I do not see it in the webpage. "Прізвище ГАЛУШКА налічує 5374 носіїв." - When? Today? in 2024? in 2028?

  Please do not restor your edit until the discussion is not finished. --Altenmann >talk 23:49, 3 January 2025 (UTC)