Seoul City Sue

Anna Wallis Suh
Suh in Korea, c. 1930
Born	Anna Lois Wallis 1900 Lawrence County, Arkansas, U.S.
Died	1969 (aged 68–69) North Korea
Nationality	American Japanese (1938–1945) South Korean (1948–1969) North Korean (1950–1969)
Other names	Seoul City Sue Anna Wallace Suhr
Education	Southeastern State Teachers College Scarritt College for Christian Workers
Occupation	Educator
Employer(s)	Methodist Missionary Organization Shanghai American School U.S. Legation Seoul Korean Central News Agency
Known for	Announcing propaganda on North Korean radio during the Korean War
Spouse	Sŏ Kyu Ch’ŏl (서규철 徐奎哲)
Parent(s)	Albert B. and M. J. Wallis

Anna Wallis Suh (1900–1969), the woman generally associated^[1] with the nickname "Seoul City Sue," was an American Methodist missionary, educator, and North Korean propaganda radio announcer to United States forces during the Korean War.

Suh was born in Arkansas, the youngest of six children. After her mother and father died in 1910 and 1914, she relocated to Oklahoma to join a sister's family while she completed high school. She spent her early adult years as an office clerk and Sunday school teacher. Subsequently, she studied at the Southeastern State Teachers College, in Durant, and the Scarritt College for Christian Workers in Nashville, Tennessee, graduating in 1930 with a B.A. in ministry. She spent the next eight years working as a member of the American Southern Methodist Episcopal Mission in Korea, then under Japanese rule. As Japanese authorities continued to restrict the activities of foreign missions, Suh joined the staff of Shanghai American School (SAS) in 1938. There she met and married fellow staff member Sŏ Kyu Ch’ŏl, thus losing her United States citizenship.^[2] Late in World War II she was interned by the Japanese for two years with Americans and Europeans at a camp in suburban Shanghai. After release, she resumed work at SAS for a year, before returning to Korea with her husband in 1946.

The Suhs settled in Seoul, where Suh taught at the U.S. Legation school until being fired in 1949 due to suspicion of her husband for left wing political activities. They remained or were trapped in Seoul during the Northern army's invasion of South Korea in June 1950. Suh began announcing a short English language program for North Korean "Radio Seoul" starting on or about July 18, continuing until shortly after the Inchon landing on September 15, when the Suhs were evacuated north as a part of the general withdrawal of North Korean forces. Subsequently, she continued broadcasts on Radio Pyongyang. The Suhs participated in the political indoctrination of US POWs at a camp near Pyongyang in February 1951.

Charles Robert Jenkins, an American who defected to and then left North Korea, reported that Suh was put in charge of English language publications for the Korean Central News Agency after the war. Jenkins also stated that he was told in 1972 that Suh had been shot as a South Korean double agent in 1969.

Suh was born Anna Wallis to Albert B. and M. Jane Wallis in 1900 in Lawrence County, Arkansas. She was the youngest of six children.^[3]

Suh's parents died when she was young; her mother died some time between the 1900 and 1910 Census,^[4][5] and her father in October 1914.^[6] Subsequently, she relocated to Oklahoma with a sister.^[7] Suh attended the Southeastern State Teachers College, in Durant, Oklahoma, where she was a member of the Student Volunteer Movement. During her junior year, she was selected to attend the organization's 1928 quadrennial convention in Detroit.^[8] In 1929, she transferred to the Scarritt College for Christian Workers, an institution dedicated to the training of Methodist missionaries, in Nashville, Tennessee. Ann graduated with a B.A. in 1930.^[9]

That same year, she was selected for a mission to Korea by the Southern Methodist Conference.^[10] There, she initially taught at a Methodist school.^[11] By the early 1930s, the Japanese colonial administration had largely banned foreigners from Christian proselytizing, and most Christian missions focused on education, medicine, and care for the indigent.^[12] She may have returned to the US in 1935 to visit a sister.^[13] In late 1936, she was appointed to serve at the Seoul Social Evangelistic Center, and in February 1937, visited Scarritt College during a missionary furlough.^[14]

In a move that may have reflected increasingly harsh Japanese measures against foreign missionaries in the late 30s,^[12][15] Suh relocated to China to join the staff of the Shanghai American School (SAS) in 1938. There she met Sŏ Kyu Ch’ŏl (서규철 徐奎哲, also spelled Suh Kyoon Chul), who was hired to teach Korean and assist in school administration. They married at the United States Court for China on December 9, 1939.^[16] She was dropped from the rolls of the missionary service and lost her United States citizenship after they married. She developed an interest in Korean politics, eventually taking up her husband's leftist views.^[17][18][19] The cosmopolitan Shanghai International Settlement and French Concession were likely a more accepting environment for the Suhs than homogeneous 1940s Korea would later prove to be, as suggested by the number of other Caucasian women on staff married to Asian men.^[20][21] In 1939, she visited San Francisco in an unsuccessful attempt to secure a US passport for her husband.^[22]

Americans in Shanghai began to depart that same year, slowly as tensions rose in the environs of the city, then en masse shortly before the US and Japan officially went to war. SAS remained open until February 1943,^[23] when the remaining foreign staff were forced into the Chapei Civilian Relocation Center, a short distance away in the northern suburbs.^[20] This internment camp, one of several in and around Shanghai, occupied a three-story dormitory on the grounds of Great China University (now East China Normal University), most of which was damaged or destroyed during the 1937 Battle of Shanghai.^[24]

In March 1943, Suh also entered the Chapei center along with the remaining non-Asian school staff,^[25] while her husband may have remained free as a colonial subject of Japan. During the internment, the SAS staff and parents took advantage of the school's books that had followed them to organize classes for the children. Supplies with which to maintain the internees grew short towards the end of the war, and a number of women married to citizens of Axis powers or neutral countries were released in late 1944. It is possible that Suh was among these.^[26] In March 1943, a missionary family, R.W. and M.F. Howes, along with their two girls, were interned in Chapei—the Japanese official name was Chapei Civil Assembly Center. Most of the people were Canadian or American, with some central European citizens. And later some British citizens were added from a camp further west up the Yangtze which the Japanese closed.

In December 1943, she was staying at Shanghai General Hospital, originally a Catholic hospital, but during the war under Japanese control though still staffed by Catholic sisters.

Suh was released from the Chapei center and returned to Shanghai in June 1944.^[27]

With Suh's formal release from detention at the end of World War II,^[28] she joined the staff of the reconstituted SAS for the 1945-46 school year.^[20]

Unable to continue earning a sufficient living in post-war Shanghai,^[22] she and her husband returned to liberated Korea, where she tutored children at the US Diplomatic Mission School in Seoul. Her employment was terminated after her husband was investigated for left wing activities.^[29] Shortly thereafter, North Korea invaded the South in June 1950.

The Korean People's Army occupied Seoul three days after the start of hostilities. The speed of the advance caught the majority of residents by surprise and unprepared to evacuate, in part due to ROK radio propaganda rather at odds with the actual situation.^[30][31] Suh and her husband remained as well, perhaps because he was unwilling to abandon a school for indigent boys that he administered. During a July 10 meeting in Seoul that included 48 to 60 members of the ROK National Assembly, the couple pledged their loyalty to the North Korean regime.^[32][33]

Under Dr. Lee Soo, an English instructor from Seoul University, Suh began announcing for North Korean "Radio Seoul" from the Korean Broadcasting System's HLKA studios, with daily programs from 09:30 to 22:15 local time,^[34] first heard as early as July 18. The Suhs had been relocated to a temporary home near the station.^[17] Suh's defenders gave the dull tone of her broadcasts as proof that she was being forced to make them.^[35]

Her initial scripts suggested that American soldiers return to their corner ice cream stands, criticized the USAF bombing campaign, and reported names recovered from the dog tags of dead American soldiers to a background of soft music.^[36][37] The GIs gave her various nicknames, including "Rice Ball-" or "Rice Bowl Maggie", "Rice Ball Kate", and "Seoul City Sue".^[38][39] The latter name stuck, likely derived from "Sioux City Sue",^[40] the title of a song initially made popular by Zeke Manners^[41][42][43] from 1946. Through the rest of the summer of 1950, her reports would announce the names of recently captured US airmen, marines, and soldiers,^[44][45][46] threaten new units arriving in the country,^[47] welcome warships by name as they arrived on station,^[48] or taunt African-American soldiers regarding their limited civil rights at home.^[49] Her monotone on-air delivery and the lack of popular music programming evidently left Suh's broadcasts less enjoyable for her intended audience than German and Japanese English-language radio shows during World War II.^[50]

Radio Seoul went off the air at the start of a "Sue" program during an August 13 air strike on communications and transportation facilities in the city, as a B-26 bomber dropped 200 lbs fragmentation bombs adjacent to the transmitter. The station came back on the air a week or two later.^[51] The Suhs were evacuated north by truck after the Inchon landings, a few days before US forces entered the city.^[52][53][54] The Suhs joined the staff of Radio Pyongyang, where she continued English-language broadcasts to UN forces. They were temporarily reassigned to indoctrinate UN POWs at Camp 12 near Pyongyang in February 1951, after which the POWs were directed to continue indoctrinating each other, with Korean supervision.^[55]

Fellow defector Charles Robert Jenkins made several claims about Suh in his book The Reluctant Communist that have not been independently verified. He reported that, some time after the war, she was put in charge of English language publications for the Korean Central News Agency. He wrote that he saw her in a photo for a 1962 propaganda pamphlet called "I Am A Lucky Boy", dining with Larry Allen Abshier, a US Army deserter and defector. Jenkins reported meeting her briefly in 1965 at the "foreigners only" section of the No. 2 Department Store in Pyongyang. Jenkins also stated that he was told in 1972 that Suh had been shot as a South Korean double agent in 1969.^[56]

Based on US law through the 1930s, citizenship for a married woman was almost exclusively based on that of her husband, particularly if they lived in his native land. Therefore, Suh probably lost her US citizenship when she married Suh Kyoon Chul in China.^[2] Suh Kyoon Chul, as well as all other native residents of Korea and Taiwan, were nationals of the Empire of Japan, which recognized itself as a multi-ethnic state.^[57][58] Suh may not have recognized her situation until the 1939 visit to San Francisco to secure a US passport for her husband. In addition to her status as a Japanese national, the US had almost completely frozen Asian immigration with the Immigration Act of 1924, which would likely have precluded his obtaining a passport.

Arbitrary application of Japanese and US law may have dogged Suh over the following years. When the Japanese interned most ethnic Europeans within the Empire during World War II, it is not clear whether she was forced into the Chapei Relocation Center, or entered it willingly, since she was not a foreign national. Later, during the US military occupation of southern Korea, an attempt was made to restore her US citizenship, an effort which fell through for unknown reasons.^[17][22] It is possible that she became a national of South Korea as the wife of Mr. Suh. The Korean nationality that became reestablished between the end of World War II and the formal independence of the ROK in 1948 didn't distinguish between spouses.^[59] Although US forces sought her out after retaking Seoul in September 1950, officials recognized that it was unlikely that Suh could be charged with treason by the US.^[17][22]

During the Korean War, USAF pilots improvised a spoof of the Zeke Manner's hit "Sioux City Sue" using the most popular nickname for Suh.^[60]

In several episodes of the TV series M*A*S*H a North Korean announcer calling herself "Seoul City Sue" is heard on the radio (rebroadcast over the camp's PA). In "Bombed" she tells the GIs that their wives and girlfriends are being unfaithful and they would have more prosperous careers as civilians. In "38 Across" she accuses Hawkeye Pierce of war crimes for performing an experimental technique to successfully save the life of a North Korean POW.^[61]

• Propaganda in North Korea
• Pyongyang Sally

Notes

Bibliography

• Franklin, Dan (December 31, 1996). "Smith-L Archives, Seoul City Sue". rootsweb.com. Archived from the original on October 13, 2012. Retrieved April 26, 2009. I talked with the 8th Army Historian in Seoul. All he had was that Seoul City Sue was not one person, but the voice of several different women.
• Twelfth Census of the United States, United States census, 1900; Strawberry, Lawrence, Arkansas; roll T623 64, page 10B, line 88. Retrieved on April 27, 2009.
• Thirteenth Census of the United States, United States census, 1910; Strawberry, Lawrence, Arkansas; roll T624 55, page 9B, line 77. Retrieved on April 27, 2009.
• "Certificate of Death, Dates 1914-1923, Wallis, Albert B, Volume 030, Certificate 00765". ancestry.com. June 30, 1914. Retrieved April 28, 2009.
• ""Seoul City Sue" Remembered As A Beautiful Girl". Mount Pleasant, Iowa, USA: Mount Pleasant News. INS. October 3, 1950. p. 1. Retrieved April 29, 2009.
• "The Southeastern 1928" (PDF). Southeastern State Teachers College, Oklahoma. p. 149. Retrieved October 28, 2021.
• Scarritt College Commencement. Virginia D. Laskey Research Library, Scarritt-Bennett Center, Nashville, Tenn.: Scarritt College for Christian Workers. 1930.
• "20 Young Women to Be Consecrated at Woman's Missionary Council March 13–18". Denton, Texas: Denton Record Chronicle. INS. March 7, 1930. p. 1. Retrieved April 29, 2009.
• "Certificate of Marriage, American Consular Service, Shanghai, China". US Department of State. December 9, 1939. Retrieved November 27, 2021. Certificate of Marriage, American Consular Service, Shanghai, China, Form No. 87, December 9, 1939
• SGM Herbert A. Friedman (Ret.) (January 5, 2006). "Communist North Korean War Leaflets". Pennsylvania: PSYOPS & PSYWAR: Psychological Operations Psychological Warfare. Retrieved April 30, 2009.
• Kim, Andrew E. (1997). "Christianity In Korea, The Shinto Shrine Controversy and Japanese Oppression". Kirkland, Washington: Korea WebWeekly. Retrieved April 30, 2009.
• "New York Passenger Lists, 1820-1957". Archived from the original on June 18, 2022. Retrieved April 30, 2009. A list of United States Citizens on the S.S. Europa, sailing from Southampton, arriving at port of New York, September 9, 1935. Compare destination address against record of Ms. Wallis' sister, Mrs. Ruth N. Battles, in the Fifteenth Census of the United States.
• Fifteenth Census of the United States, United States census, 1930; Carnegie, Caddo, Oklahoma; roll 1894, page 13B, line 90. Retrieved on April 27, 2009.
• Scarritt College Voice. Vol. IX (1 ed.). Virginia D. Laskey Research Library, Scarritt-Bennett Center, Nashville, Tenn.: Scarritt College for Christian Workers. 1937. Recent news from Ann Wallis ('30) tells of her new appointment at the Social Evangelistic Center at Seoul, Korea. She and Margaret Billingsly have rooms at the Center, but take their meals across the yards. The settlement is similar to our settlement houses, with its clinic, kindergarten, etc. Ann's particular task, among many others, is teaching in the night school and helping with the clubs and English classes during the day.
• "United Methodist Church, General Board of Global Ministries Country Profiles: Korea". Archived from the original on June 26, 2007.
• Edwards, Paul M. (2000). To Acknowledge A War: the Korean War in American memory. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 79. ISBN 0-313-31021-1.
• Lech, Raymond B. (2000). Broken Soldiers. University of Illinois Press. pp. 118–121. ISBN 0-252-02541-5.
• "Seoul City Sue American-Born Ex-Missionary, Says Intelligence". Portland Sunday Telegram And Sunday Press Herald. Portland, Maine. UP. October 4, 1950. p. 1. Archived from the original (Reprint) on November 26, 2009. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Mills, Angie; Phoebe White Wentworth (1997). Fair is the Name: The Story of the Shanghai American School, 1912-1950. Los Angeles: Shanghai American School Association. ASIN B0006F9Y3S.
• Choi, Hyaeweol (2003). "An American Concubine in Old Korea: Missionary Discourse on Gender, Race, and Modernity". Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies. 24 (3). University of Nebraska Press: 134–161. doi:10.1353/fro.2004.0059. S2CID 146651255. Wagner's novel might have been inspired by an actual event in Korea -- an American woman falling in love with a Korean man. In her correspondence dated May 24, 1948, she wrote, 'I've forgotten, but of course you remember Allyeu [Wagner's brother-in-law]. I still laugh when I remember how shocked Allyeu was in Seoul at Ann Wallace and her Korean sweetheart. By the way, did you see Ann while you were in Seoul? She evidently has had a pretty tough time, but what could she expect?
• "Oklahoman Thinks 'Seoul City Sue' Is Sister; Being Forced Into Broadcasting". Coshocton Tribune. Coshocton, Ohio. UP. August 30, 1950. p. 1. Archived from the original (Reprint) on June 18, 2022. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Leck, Greg (2005). "The Camps". The Japanese Internment of Allied Civilians in China and Hong Kong, 1941-1945. Archived from the original on December 20, 2005. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Leck, Greg (2006). Captives Of Empire: The Japanese Internment Of Allied Civilians In China, 1941 1945. Shandy Press. p. 545. ISBN 0-9772141-0-9.
• "World II Prisoners of War Data File, 12/7/1941 - 11/19/1946". National Archives At the NARA-AAD. Retrieved May 2, 2009. A search within this file for 'suh anna' returns a record for "Suh, Anna W, Mrs., Civilian, Status Repatriated, Chapei Civilian Assembly Center Shanghai 31-121."
• Johnston, Richard J.H. (August 28, 1950). "Missionaries Say 'Seoul City Sue' Is Ann Suhr, U.S. Wife of Korean" (Fee required). The New York Times. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• "Episode 5, Korea: Interview With Hong An". National Security Archive. October 25, 1998. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Young Sik, Kim (July 29, 2004). "Korean War Starts". Eyewitness: A North Korean Remembers. Archived from the original on August 11, 2007. Retrieved May 3, 2009. June 29 - N. Korean Army takes Seoul - It is weird. We see pictures of N Korean soldiers marching in Seoul and yet Seoul Radio is still claiming some fantastic victories!! How can this be?
• Young Sik, Kim (July 29, 2004). "Korean War 1950: War of Unification". Eyewitness: A North Korean Remembers. Archived from the original on August 13, 2007. Retrieved May 3, 2009. July 10, 1950...More than 60 members of the Republic of Korea National Assembly join the N Korean cause., for bibliography, see https://web.archive.org/web/20080720082409/http://www.kimsoft.com/korea/eyewit33.htm.
• Quigg, H.D. (September 12, 1950). "Seoul City Sue Talks Too Much, Not Enough Music" (Reprint). Corpus Chrisi Times. UP. p. 9. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Mitchell, Charles R. (September 18, 1950). "Letters, Re "Seoul City Sue"". Time Magazine. Archived from the original (Reprint) on November 6, 2009. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• "GIs Nickname Reds' Radiocaster As "Seoul City Sue"" (Reprint). Yuma Daily Sun. UP. August 10, 1950. p. 1. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Martin, Bradley K. (2004). Under The Loving Care Of The Fatherly Leader: N. Korea and the Kim Dynasty. Macmillan. pp. 76–77. ISBN 0-312-32221-6.
• 83-1: Executive Sessions of The Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations of The Committee on Government Operations, Volume 3. Vol. 3 (S. Prt 107-84 ed.). Washington, D.C.: USGPO. January 2003. p. 2025.
• Korean War atrocities: hearing before the Subcommittee on Korean War Atrocities of the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations of the Committee on Government Operations. Washington, D.C.: USGPO. 1954. p. 48.
• Lynne Rossi Ruelan (November 10, 2004). "SIOUX CITY SUE - 1945, Music by Dick Thomas & Lyrics by Ray Freedman". Tribute To Dick Thomas Goldhahn. Archived from the original on April 30, 2009. Retrieved May 3, 2009. I drove a herd of cattle down, from old Nebraska way...
• Martin, Douglas (November 3, 2000). "Zeke Manners, 'Hillbilly' Who Ruled Radio, Dies at 89". The New York Times. NY, NY, USA. Archived from the original (Reprint) on January 30, 2013. Retrieved October 6, 2010.
• Ruelan, Lynne Rossi (November 10, 2004). "Soundtrack: Sioux City Sue, Zeke Manners". Tribute To Dick Thomas Goldhahn. Archived from the original on July 16, 2011. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• "Red Broadcaster Dubbed 'Seoul City Sue' by G.I.'s" (fee required). The New York Times. AP. August 9, 1950. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Wosser, Joseph Lloyd (February 2, 2009). "Transcribed letters re: Seoul City Sue". Death Rattlers, Marine Fighter Squadron 323 (VMF-323). Thomas "TC" Crouson. Archived from the original on November 18, 2001. Retrieved May 3, 2009. Sept 9 At sea. Today I had another CAP so it was just another three hours on the parachute. Capt Booker was on Seoul City Sue's program today so he must be OK if they are advertising the fact that he is a POW.
• Bernard, Carl F. (October 8, 1999). "Commentary; Perspective on Warfare; 'We Were a Speed Bump for the North Koreans'". Los Angeles Times. p. 9. ISSN 0458-3035. ProQuest 421473079.
• Whitten, H. Wayne. "1st MAW Det USS Valley Forge (CV-45) History". Marine Corps Aviation Reconnaissance Association (MCARA). Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Stocks, Floyd P. "Corsairs Over Korea". Archived from the original on June 19, 2002. Retrieved May 3, 2009. Radio Seoul threatens captured Marine aviators with death., scroll down to "13 August 1950".
• Schratz, Paul R. (2000). Submarine Commander. University Press of Kentucky. p. 304. ISBN 0-8131-0988-4.
• Lipsitz, George (1995). A Life in the Struggle: Ivory Perry and the Culture of Opposition. Temple University Press. p. 56. ISBN 1-56639-321-3.
• "Bombers Silence Seoul Radio" (fee required). The New York Times. August 14, 1950. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• "Details of the silencing of 'seoul city sue' by an american bomber crew were related in a recorded broadcast from tokyo". The Stars and Stripes, European Edition. August 22, 1950. Archived from the original (reprint) on June 18, 2022. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Johnston, Richard J.H. (October 4, 1950). "Enemy 'Doctored' G.I. Broadcasts" (reprint). The New York Times. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Jaffe, Sam (October 5, 1950). "'Seoul City Sue' Was U.S. Missionary" (reprint). The Stars & Stripes. INS. p. 2. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• William Shinn (March 8, 1952). "'Seoul City Sue' Said to Have Once Been Missionary". The Chillicothe Constitution Tribute. p. 1. Archived from the original (reprint) on June 18, 2022. Retrieved May 3, 2009.
• Jenkins, Charles Robert (2008). The Reluctant Communist: My Desertion, Court-Martial, and Forty-Year Imprisonment in North Korea. University of California Press. pp. 115–116. ISBN 978-0-520-25333-9.
• asiatrails (November 27, 2007). "Forum: Air Force Life, Fighter Pilot Songs". F-16.net. Retrieved May 2, 2009. Seoul City Sue (Tune - Sioux City Sue): I drove a herd of oxen down, till I reached old Bong Chong Way...
• Diffrient, David Scott (2008). M*A*S*H. Wayne State University Press. p. 121. ISBN 978-0-8143-3347-1.
• Smith, Marian L. (1998). "Women and Naturalization". United States National Archives, Prolog Magazine.
• Lie, John (2004). Multiethnic Japan. Harvard University Press. p. 122. ISBN 0-674-01358-1.
• Schaeffer, Angela Paik (2005). "Rethinking Citizenship". The Johns Hopkins University, Zanvyl Krieger School of Arts and Sciences, Arts & Sciences Magazine. Archived from the original on June 6, 2010. Retrieved August 7, 2009.
• "World Directory of Minorities and Indigenous Peoples - Japan : Koreans". Minority Rights Group International. 2008. Retrieved August 6, 2009.

• Time Magazine, August 21, 1950 Vol. LVI No. 8
• Korean War Discussion List email archives
• United States Army In The Korean War: South To The Naktong, North To The Yalu Archived February 7, 2014, at the Wayback Machine a publication of the United States Army Center of Military History
  • Ibid, Footnote 51 Archived September 25, 2021, at the Wayback Machine
• Army News Service
• "Eyewitness: A North Korean Remembers"
• "The History Listen: Seoul City Sue", produced by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, 2016.